Jobs Recovery Increasingly Uneven as Talent Gap Widens

In June, total job openings in the U.S. grew to 3.76 million, according to the Labor Department, the highest level since the summer of 2008. In the past 36 months, job openings have grown more than 70 percent, far surpassing the recovery following the last recession, in which job openings grew just 47 percent in the same time frame.

Meanwhile, the unemployment rate has fared worse in the 36 months following the current recession than in the previous one. Between September 2003 and September 2006, unemployment fell 25 percent from its peak, from 6 percent to 4.5 percent, while in the current recovery’s 36-month period, unemployment has fallen only 14 percent, from 9.6 to 8.3 percent. So where is the disconnect between job openings and falling unemployment rates?

“Enough confidence has returned to the market that most employers have lifted blanket hiring freezes and are expanding the range of positions they are working to fill outside of those directly tied to incremental revenue,” says Rob Romaine, president of MRINetwork. “We are seeing search activity growing across more functions, but actually making that final hiring decision among most employers has only increased slightly.”

Recruiters continue to report that hiring processes have been drawn out by managers having unrealistic expectations of candidate credentials and experience in the current unemployment situation. Yet, evidence shows that the top candidates such managers are looking for are more likely to reject offers the longer the hiring process becomes.

“In the recruiting industry, we talk a lot about the importance of having a streamlined interview and offer process regardless of the state of the economy because while there is high unemployment, there is also a growing talent mismatch in the United States. What this means is that while there are plenty who are unemployed, there are still very few who fit the needs of a given pasteurization in the professional space,” notes Romaine.

In nominal, non-adjusted numbers, total U.S. employment peaked in August 2008 and fell precipitously for 15 months, reversing course in January 2010. In that time, nearly 11.5 million jobs were eliminated. The professional and business services sector-about 13 percent of the U.S. private workforce-lost nearly 2 million of those jobs. The construction industry, which represented less than 7 percent of the private workforce, lost 3 million jobs from peak to trough.

In the two years since that employment trough, the professional services segment of the workforce has returned all but about 200,000 positions. In fact, the much broader U.S. service providing sector, which accounts for more than 80 percent of the 113 million U.S. private sector jobs, has recovered all but about 300,000 positions. Of the 4.2 million-job decline since the peak of U.S. employment, half of those positions-2.1 million-are in construction, and another 1.8 million are in manufacturing.

“With today’s levels of advanced training, certifications, and degrees it can be difficult to move between even similar career paths quickly,” says Romaine. “But going from a factory floor or construction site to a professional office job is such a fundamental change that it requires both training and a veritable career restart. Such a change of course is possible, but the availability of such workers does little for employers looking for experienced professionals today.”

It could take several more years for the mix of skills in the U.S. talent market to properly recalibrate. In that time, unemployment will remain heightened while the skills of the workforce move to more closely match the requirements of job openings today.

News/Insights

The Power of Emotional Intelligence in the Doctor-Patient Relationship Job Market/Industry News

The Power of Emotional Intelligence in the Doctor-Patient Relationship

Jun 5, 2023

“Physician leaders who are able to exhibit high degrees of emotional intelligence (EI), particularly in how they manage their own emotions and react to the emotions of other...

Where Are All the Optometrists and Ophthalmologists? Hiring

Where Are All the Optometrists and Ophthalmologists?

Oct 27, 2021

 The market for Optometry and Ophthalmology talent has always been competitive. Several factors have combined to make what was already a tight market even more challenging. T...

Employment Situation Report – June 2021 Job Market/Industry News

Employment Situation Report – June 2021

Jul 2, 2021

Summary of the Bureau of Labor Statistics Monthly Employment Situation Report – June 2021 Continuing a six month increase in job growth, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Stat...

Are You Ready for What’s Next? Hiring

Are You Ready for What’s Next?

Mar 24, 2021

Everyone is trying to understand what’s coming next in a post-COVID-19 world. While we have no special foresight into the future of the pandemic, we can tell you what we hav...

Employment Situation Report – February 2021 Job Market/Industry News

Employment Situation Report – February 2021

Mar 10, 2021

Summary of the Bureau of Labor Statistics Monthly Employment Situation Report The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) today reported total nonfarm payroll employment incr...

Employment Situation Report – January 2021 Job Market/Industry News

Employment Situation Report – January 2021

Feb 11, 2021

Summary of the Bureau of Labor Statistics Monthly Employment Situation Report The January job gain of 49,000 was in-line with most analysts’ expectations and represented ...

Employment Situation Report – December 2020 Job Market/Industry News

Employment Situation Report – December 2020

Jan 14, 2021

Summary of the Bureau of Labor Statistics Monthly Employment Situation Report Total nonfarm payroll employment declined by 140,000 in December, well below the consensus forec...

Employment Summary for November 2020 Job Market/Industry News

Employment Summary for November 2020

Dec 7, 2020

Summary of the Bureau of Labor Statistics Monthly Employment Situation Report The U.S. economy added 245,000 non-farm jobs in November, below the 410,...

Employment Summary for October 2020 Job Market/Industry News

Employment Summary for October 2020

Nov 20, 2020

The U.S. economy added 638,000 non-farm jobs in October, above the 530,000-job growth expected by economists. The unemployment rate declined to 6.6 percent. October is the six...

Employment Summary for September 2020 Job Market/Industry News

Employment Summary for September 2020

Oct 5, 2020

Summary of the Bureau of Labor Statistics Monthly Employment Situation Report The U.S. economy added 661,000 non-farm jobs in September, below the 800,000 job growth expected...